Got a birthday party, rehearsal dinner, corporate or other event coming up? We're a great option for your gathering! Inquire today and let us know how we can make your special occasion perfect!
Cater your birthday party, holiday party, corporate events, wedding festivities and more!
We recommend making a reservation ahead of time. Book your table today!
At Carmelita's, every dish tells a story - rooted in tradition and bursting with bold, authentic flavors. From sizzling huevos rancheros and hand-rolled enchiladas to homemade salsas and refreshing margaritas, our menu celebrates the rich heritage of Mexican cooking. Enjoy a variety of gluten-free dishes, each prepared with fresh, high-quality organic ingredients and spices.
There are currently 5 menu items in the viewport, and the slider navigation buttons are previous and next buttons. The previous/next buttons are preceding menu items. On previous/next button activation, the carousel moves for 1 menu item.
La Familia Sampler
$15.95
Tinga Nachos
$16.95
Maria’s Nachos
$16.95
Nacho Flight
$15.95
Super Nachos (TAKEOUT ONLY)
$34.95
Brooke’s
$9.95
Mi Marido’s
$10.95
Zapata's Tacos
$11.95
Taco Flight (Thursdays)
$29.95
Shrimp Tacos (Fridays)
$14.95
Birria Tacos (Fridays & Saturdays)
$6.50/ea.
Breakfast Quesadilla
$15.95
Huevos Rancheros
$15.95
French Toast
$11.95
Whether it's a birthday, anniversary, family reunion, or office gathering, Carmelita's is the perfect place to celebrate. Our welcoming space and festive atmosphere set the stage for unforgettable moments - and our delicious Mexican food brings everyone together!
Book a partyLet Carmelita's cater your next event with the bold, authentic flavors everyone loves. Whether you're planning a corporate lunch, family gathering, holiday party, or special celebration, we'll provide fresh, crowd-pleasing Mexican dishes that are sure to impress.
Carmelita’s Mexican Restaurant in Cicero, NY, is the proud second generation of a beloved family-run eatery that many remember fondly from Syracuse in the 70's. Our roots run deep in tradition, and we’ve brought back the same authentic recipes, fresh ingredients, and welcoming spirit that made the original Carmelita’s a local favorite.
My girlfriend and I love coming to Carmelita's! They have amazing gluten free dishes, and we love the queso and salsa. Food always tastes so fresh and you genuinely can't choose wrong on the menu. The servers are always so kind and the place feels efficiently run! We're excited to try the brunch soon.
If I could give this place all the stars in the world I would!! Service is absolutely incredible, you won't get this type of service anywhere else!! The food, absolutely DELICIOUS!! Everyone here is so friendly and welcoming. Highly highly recommended!
Best kept secret in Cicero hands down. Top tier hospitality when you walk in the door all the employees there were really polite. Service was fantastic. And the food is mouth watering.
Loved the ambiance, quick service, cultured food, fast service and the dessert was the most tasteful I've ever tasted. Highly recommended I came with my family members and everyone ordered different meals. Surprisingly each member was content. Highly recommended
Family owned, authentic food. Owner stopped over to our table a couple times and was just absolutely pleasant to speak with. Great food and drinks!
